Understanding vs. Generation: Navigating Optimization Dilemma in Multimodal Models
Sen Ye, Mengde Xu, Shuyang Gu, Di He, Liwei Wang, Han Hu
2026-02-18
Summary
This paper investigates a problem with current artificial intelligence models that can 'see' and 'speak' – called multimodal models – where making them better at creating things, like writing captions for images, often makes them worse at understanding things, and vice versa.
What's the problem?
The core issue is that improving a model's ability to generate content and its ability to understand information seem to work against each other. It's like trying to make a student both really creative *and* really good at analyzing texts; focusing too much on one skill can hurt the other. The researchers believe this happens because the model's resources are split between these two competing tasks.
What's the solution?
To fix this, the researchers created a new method called Reason-Reflect-Refine, or R3. Instead of having the model try to generate an answer in one go, R3 breaks it down into three steps: first, the model generates an initial response, then it 'understands' what it wrote, and finally, it uses that understanding to improve and refine its answer. This way, understanding isn't just a separate skill, but an active part of the generation process.
Why it matters?
This research is important because it provides a new way to build more capable and well-rounded AI models. By showing how to balance generation and understanding, it paves the way for future AI systems that can both create and comprehend information effectively, leading to more useful and intelligent applications.
Abstract
Current research in multimodal models faces a key challenge where enhancing generative capabilities often comes at the expense of understanding, and vice versa. We analyzed this trade-off and identify the primary cause might be the potential conflict between generation and understanding, which creates a competitive dynamic within the model. To address this, we propose the Reason-Reflect-Refine (R3) framework. This innovative algorithm re-frames the single-step generation task into a multi-step process of "generate-understand-regenerate". By explicitly leveraging the model's understanding capability during generation, we successfully mitigate the optimization dilemma, achieved stronger generation results and improved understanding ability which are related to the generation process. This offers valuable insights for designing next-generation unified multimodal models. Code is available at https://github.com/sen-ye/R3.